Everton had a decent run of form leading up to the recent international break, but the pause in domestic football seemed timely. Their 0-0 draw against Newcastle United was considered a positive result due to the number of key players missing from the squad. As Everton prepares to face Ipswich Town, the dilemma arises of determining the best starting XI when the entire squad is fit.
Chris Beesley, Gavin Buckland, and Ian Croll discussed whether there is such a thing as a definitive ‘best XI’ in modern football with squad rotation and tactical variations. Beesley’s preferred lineup includes Jordan Pickford in goal, Jarrad Branthwaite, James Tarkowski, Vitalii Mykolenko in defense, and Dominic Calvert-Lewin up front. The right-back position remains a challenge with multiple players vying for the spot, including Nathan Patterson and Seamus Coleman. In midfield, the partnership between Orel Mangala and Abdoulaye Doucoure has shown promise, but the return of Idrissa Gueye adds experience to the mix.
Joe Thomas emphasizes the importance of building a long-term strategy for Everton, suggesting Nathan Patterson as the solution to the right-back dilemma. He believes Patterson’s attacking prowess could complement Jack Harrison’s work rate on the right flank. In midfield, Thomas opts for Orel Mangala and Idrissa Gueye to provide stability and support for the attacking duo of Dwight McNeil and Iliman Ndiaye.
Matt Jones highlights the key decisions facing Sean Dyche, particularly at right-back and in midfield. While Seamus Coleman’s leadership qualities make him a strong candidate for the defensive role, Orel Mangala’s composure in possession could complement Idrissa Gueye’s playing style. The attacking trio behind Dominic Calvert-Lewin presents some tactical considerations, with Dwight McNeil’s offensive contributions balanced against defensive concerns.
As Everton navigates the squad dilemma with returning players, the debate over the best starting XI continues. The blend of experience, skill, and tactical understanding will be crucial in maintaining the team’s performance levels. The upcoming matches will test the manager’s ability to make the right choices based on form, fitness, and strategic considerations. It remains to be seen how Everton will tackle the positional uncertainty and field a lineup that maximizes the potential of the entire squad.
